by Marcus Loane
When debating, in person or in written (typed!?) word
here are some tips:
Do not attack, criticise, ridicule or try
to psychoanalyse your "opponent". Attack his/her
argument. You may as a side issue wonder about
their motives but that is a poor substitute for saying
what is wrong with their argument. Try not to slip into a
combative mode - don't make it personal.
Do not conclude an argument is fallacious
because of the character of its proponent. It is the argument
itself that matters.
Do not conclude an argument is sound
because of the proponent's credentials. (eg. He is an
intelligent lawyer so he must be right). It is the argument
itself that matters.
Try to set premises that your opponent
agrees with and then show what logically follows. If you
do not agree on the premises, the debate breaks down.
I am probably guilty of contravening all of the above. With
practice you can improve. When someone attacks your character or
motives, ignore it and get them back on to the subject you are
debating. Righteous indignation leads nowhere.
--
Marcus Loane